Current:Home > Contact-usFederal judge rejects request from Oregon senators who boycotted Legislature seeking to run in 2024-DB Wealth Institute B2 Expert Reviews
Federal judge rejects request from Oregon senators who boycotted Legislature seeking to run in 2024
View Date:2024-12-23 22:40:54
PORTLAND, Ore. (AP) — A federal judge has rejected a request from Oregon Republican state senators who boycotted the Legislature to be allowed on the ballot after their terms end.
U.S. District Court Judge Ann Aiken issued the decision Wednesday.
State Sens. Dennis Linthicum, Brian Boquist and Cedric Hayden were among the plaintiffs who filed the federal lawsuit to challenge their disqualification from running for reelection under Measure 113. The voter-approved constitutional amendment, which passed by a wide margin last year, bars legislators from seeking reelection after 10 or more unexcused absences.
Each of the three senators racked up more than 10 absences during a record six-week walkout that paralyzed the 2023 legislative session. The boycott stemmed from bills on abortion, transgender health care and guns.
The lawmakers sought, among other things, a preliminary injunction to prevent the secretary of state’s office from enforcing their disqualification from the ballot. The office in September disqualified Linthicum and Boquist from the 2024 ballot, court filings show. Hayden’s term ends in January 2027.
The senators argued that walkouts are a form of political protest protected by the First Amendment of the U.S. Constitution.
“The Senators were punished solely for exercising their First Amendment rights,” their attorneys said in court filings.
Aiken disagreed with their claims in her opinion.
“However, these walkouts were not simply protests — they were an exercise of the Senator Plaintiffs’ official power and were meant to deprive the legislature of the power to conduct business,” she wrote.
“Their subsequent disqualification is the effect of Measure 113 working as intended by the voters of Oregon,” she added.
The Oregon Senate and House of Representatives must have two-thirds of their members present in order to have a quorum and conduct business. In recent years, Republicans have protested against Democratic policies by walking out of the Legislature and denying a quorum in a bid to stall bills.
The federal suit named Secretary of State LaVonne Griffin-Valade and Democratic Senate President Rob Wagner as defendants. The senators claimed, among other things, that Wagner violated their First Amendment right to freedom of expression and their Fourteenth Amendment right to due process by marking their absences as unexcused.
Attorneys from Oregon’s justice department representing Griffin-Valade and Wagner argued the First Amendment does not protect legislators’ refusal to attend legislative floor sessions.
“Under Oregon law, a senator’s absence has an important legal effect: without the attendance of the two-thirds of senators needed to achieve a quorum, the Senate cannot legislate,” they wrote in court filings.
The federal court decision was issued one day before the Oregon Supreme Court heard a separate challenge to the measure. In oral arguments before the state’s high court in Salem Thursday, a lawyer for a different group of Republican state senators argued that confusion over the wording of the constitutional amendment means that legislators whose terms end in January can run in 2024.
Griffin-Valade, the secretary of state, is also a defendant in that lawsuit. Earlier this year, she said the boycotting senators were disqualified from seeking reelection in 2024. She directed her office’s elections division to implement an administrative rule to clarify the stance. She said the rule reflected the intent of voters when they approved the measure last year.
All parties in the suit are seeking clarity on the issue before the March 2024 filing deadline for candidates who want to run in next year’s election.
veryGood! (1132)
Related
- KFC sues Church's Chicken over 'original recipe' fried chicken branding
- US women’s professional volleyball void is filled, and possibly overflowing, with 3 upstart leagues
- Biden unveils nearly $5 billion in new infrastructure projects
- Washington Wizards move head coach Wes Unseld Jr. to front office advisory role
- California teen pleads guilty in Florida to making hundreds of ‘swatting’ calls across the US
- How Sean Lowe and Catherine Giudici Bested Those Bachelor Odds
- Court takes new look at whether Musk post illegally threatened workers with loss of stock options
- West Virginia lawmakers reject bill to expand DNA database to people charged with certain felonies
- Rep. Michael McCaul of Texas says he was detained in airport over being ‘disoriented’
- Losing a job in your 50s is extremely tough. Here are 3 steps to take when layoffs happen.
Ranking
- A growing and aging population is forcing Texas counties to seek state EMS funding
- New Jersey weighs ending out-of-pocket costs for women who seek abortions
- 'Did you miss me?': Meghan McCain talks new show, leaving 'The View,' motherhood
- Remains found at a central Indiana estate are those of a man who has been missing since 1993
- Beyoncé course coming to Yale University to examine her legacy
- New Jersey weighs ending out-of-pocket costs for women who seek abortions
- Former federal agent sentenced to over 8 years for his role in illegal painkiller trafficking
- Salty: Tea advice from American chemist seeking the 'perfect' cup ignites British debate
Recommendation
-
Don't Miss This Sweet Moment Between Taylor Swift and Travis Kelce's Dads at the Kansas City Chiefs Game
-
Aspiring writer wins full-ride Angie Thomas scholarship to Belhaven
-
'Right place at the right time': Pizza delivery driver’s call leads to rescue of boy in icy pond
-
To help these school kids deal with trauma, mindfulness lessons over the loudspeaker
-
Daniele Rustioni to become Metropolitan Opera’s principal guest conductor
-
The economy grew a faster than expected 3.3% late last year
-
Mississippi legislators approve incentives for 2 Amazon Web Services data processing centers
-
New gene-editing tools may help wipe out mosquito-borne diseases